Homophobia vs. Heteronormativity
Jan. 31st, 2006 08:15 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
asterrocI was in another discussion where I realized that not everyone defines "homophobia" the same way (cross-posted with modifications).
Merriam-Webster defines homophobia as an "irrational fear of, aversion to, or discrimination against homosexuality or homosexuals." I suspect most people would agree that hate crimes and hate speech (gay-bashing) are firmly within the realm of "irrational fear of," and "aversion to." I can see where there could be differing opinions on whether "disallowing homosexuals" falls under "aversion to, or discrimination against," though I personally think so.
I take a broad view of the word "homophobic," using it to mean any person or action intentionally treating homosexuals or homosexual behavior differently from heterosexuals or heterosexual behavior, though I definitely feel that hate crimes and speech are of a much more serious order than "mere" exclusionary practices. I use the term "homophobia" the same way as I use the term "racism" or "sexism." While it is definitely less severe to keep women out of golf clubs than it is to rape women, I would classify both as sexism. Similarly, it is less severe to keep homosexuals out of the BSA than to beat them, but I still classify both as homophobia. My classification is based upon tangible actions, rather than morals. If I were to base my definitions upon morals, it would not be considered racist if a group decided to disallow black people based upon the group's belief that there was something morally abhorrent about black people (e.g., neo-Nazis).
Unintentionally treating homosexuals differently I would classify as "heteronormativity" - assuming that heterosexual is "normal" and forgetting that others exist.
I am curious as to what others think, and how you define the terms "homophobia" and "heteronormativity." I expect that there will primarily be agreement with my usage, as I've obviously got a SLOP (self-selected opinion poll) here, but I'm still curious. Maybe if you've heard others' definitions you could share those too.
Merriam-Webster defines homophobia as an "irrational fear of, aversion to, or discrimination against homosexuality or homosexuals." I suspect most people would agree that hate crimes and hate speech (gay-bashing) are firmly within the realm of "irrational fear of," and "aversion to." I can see where there could be differing opinions on whether "disallowing homosexuals" falls under "aversion to, or discrimination against," though I personally think so.
I take a broad view of the word "homophobic," using it to mean any person or action intentionally treating homosexuals or homosexual behavior differently from heterosexuals or heterosexual behavior, though I definitely feel that hate crimes and speech are of a much more serious order than "mere" exclusionary practices. I use the term "homophobia" the same way as I use the term "racism" or "sexism." While it is definitely less severe to keep women out of golf clubs than it is to rape women, I would classify both as sexism. Similarly, it is less severe to keep homosexuals out of the BSA than to beat them, but I still classify both as homophobia. My classification is based upon tangible actions, rather than morals. If I were to base my definitions upon morals, it would not be considered racist if a group decided to disallow black people based upon the group's belief that there was something morally abhorrent about black people (e.g., neo-Nazis).
Unintentionally treating homosexuals differently I would classify as "heteronormativity" - assuming that heterosexual is "normal" and forgetting that others exist.
I am curious as to what others think, and how you define the terms "homophobia" and "heteronormativity." I expect that there will primarily be agreement with my usage, as I've obviously got a SLOP (self-selected opinion poll) here, but I'm still curious. Maybe if you've heard others' definitions you could share those too.
